
Originally Posted by
juxie
Our school uses AR, however, by the time the kids hits 4th grade, the teachers stop using the program and rely on book reports, oral & written, pages and minutes logged and others.
The biggest problem with the AR system is that while my 2nd grade daughter is reading at a 5th grade level, the AR level only takes into consideration the vocabulary and sentence structure and NOT content. Many 5.0+ AR books are inappropriate for her age level and so she is stuck with limited book choices. We also here so many times kids say - well I don't want to read that it isn't enough points or it is the wrong level... this discourages reading for fun.
Our librarian has made a huge effort to teach the kids the five finger rule for fun non-school reading. This is a student should open up a book they want, turn to the middle and read to pages, every time they come to a word they don't know to put up a finger. If all five fingers are out - the book is too hard.